So here we are on the eve of Election Day. Think about it: Just 36 hours from now, we will still have no clue who the next mayor of Nashville will be. We will, though, have a runoff! More mailers! More commercials! More pandering! It’s all pretty exciting! Me? I plan to be living somewhere else by then. But you all have fun with it.
Anyway, for those of you following along at home here’s what the strong suits of the mayoral candidates appear to be (in terms of political support) after these many weeks of campaigning:
David Briley:
Strong suits: Middle-class “progressive”-types; younger people; scattered policy wonks; the “netroots” (what there are of them); gentrified East Nashville; some teachers; a few lawyers
Bob Clement:
Strong suits: Anyone who was on social security while he was a congressman; old-time Nashville Democrats; people who think Nashville’s best days were somewhere in the mid-1970s; businesspeople who don’t understand which way the wind is blowing
Karl Dean:
Strong suits: Upper-class “progressive” types; Team Purcell; people who like to think they care a lot about public education yet send their own children to private schools; Nashville Symphony season ticket holders; courthouse people; businesspeople who do understand which way the wind is blowing
Buck Dozier:
Strong suits: Church of Christ members; people who think the most important vote in their life was the one they made against horse racing 20 years ago; people who would prefer fewer gays and Mexicans hanging around the area; some police; many firefighters; Republican voters who think they’re somehow voting for a Republican because–let’s face it–Davidson County Republicans are pretty easily duped
Howard Gentry:
Strong suit: African-American voters; a smattering of “progressive” types who like the First-Black-Mayor-of-Nashville angle; a few Republican voters here and there who want to be able to say they voted for a black guy whenever anyone says they’re racists; a handful of businesspeople
I really have no idea what’s going to happen, but that won’t stop me from making a gut prediction. Here goes:
Dean 29%
Gentry 21%
Clement 21%
Dozier 14%
Briley 13%
Other 2%
I think Gentry will benefit by having the political base least likely to defect anywhere else. Briley takes voters from Dean, and Dean takes voters from Briley (more the latter, I suspect). Clement and Dozier are in the same boat, we’re just talking about different passengers (Old Nashville Democrat/Boner/Fulton voters, as opposed to the New Nashville Democrat/Bredesen/Purcell voters in the Dean-Briley camp). Gentry, I believe, doesn’t lose substantial portions of his base to anyone else in this way. His base of African-Americans, while politcally Democratic, is not closely tied to either the Old Nashville or New Nashville Democratic crowds, and, as such, stays pretty firmly in his camp.
The smart money says Dean and Clement in the runoff. I’m not very smart, so I’m going with Dean and Gentry instead. We will, of course, see.
UPDATE: I should probably explain why I have Dean with such a (relatively) high number. I’m applying the general rule that undecided voters tend to break toward the candidate with the most apparent forward momentum at the end. In this case, that’s Dean. Which means, yes, TV money wins elections. But you know that already, right?
[…] by the time the runoff occurs but Roger Abramson still likes to prognosticate on politics and he has his fortune teller hat on today: Dean 29% Gentry 21% Clement 21% Dozier 14% Briley 13% Other […]
Do you really think so? I’m a Dean supporter and even I can’t see him beating Clement that bad. But I sure hope you’re right.
I agree with GoldnI about the margin, but I would be happy about the result. LOL Roger on your descriptions for each candidate’s draw. Very funny.
I loved the parimutuel gambling joke and the mid-70s bit. Jokes about parimutuel gambling are really underrated. ![]()
I’ve been somewhat surprised at the number, and types, of voters I’ve run into who say they are pulling for Dean. You gotta remember, that in the publics eye (that would be TV) Dean has been running the longest and hardest.
Wouldn’t it be beautiful to see Clement sitting on a half a mil with nothing to spend it on come August 3rd?
Yes, it sure would. ![]()
I’ve been somewhat surprised at the number, and types, of voters I’ve run into who say they are pulling for Dean. “You gotta remember, that in the publics eye (that would be TV) Dean has been running the longest and hardest.”
Exactly so. Remember, undecided voters ultimately tend toward the candidate with the most obvious momentum. Dean is that candidate right now.
I am a Symphony season ticket holder but I can’t vote for Dean because his automated message called me. I am not going to vote for him anyway unless in a run-off against Clement.
Do you really think the Church of Christ folks would vote monolithically? You must have never attended any Church of Christ ever. Besides, those that might be tempted to vote for Dozier on those grounds are also those that would vote for Clement because he will protect them from “those dirty Mexican teenage hooligans waiting to pounce”….or is it just me that gets that impression from Clement ads.
Clement was on Gerry House’s program this morning. He was funny, smart and completely charming.
I’ll bet he wishes every voter could hear the interview. Dean would be toast.
I didn’t say monolithically; I said only “strong suits.”
Roger,
Is it possible Dean, Gentry and Clement will split the top tier votes and Briley could sneak in?
I think that is possible if progressives are the biggest voters, tomorrow. Unlikely, but possible?
What do you think?
Roger, “monolithically” was more a joke than anything else.
I’m for Buck and I think if he doesn’t win he needs me for a campaign manager. LOL
[…] That could benefit Howard Gentry and Karl Dean, who have both gained momentum of late. As Roger Abramson observed yesterday, late momentum tends to draw the attention of voters who are not as immersed in […]
DB –
Understood. Just clarifying.
Sharon –
I just don’t think there’s any way the math can work out that way.
[…] Mike asks an interesting question based on Roger Abramson’s break down of the Nashville Mayor’s race: If there were no Bob Clement or Buck Dozier in the race, which […]
Oh wow. See I’m a middle class Nashville Symphony season ticket holder — no wonder I can’t decide.
[…] not my best performance overall, but not too shabby either. Best calls: The Dean “win” and the thin Clement-Gentry […]