Mark of This Guy Falls Down points out Story Behind the Song, which catalogs songwriters’ explanations of what inspired them to write a given song. As a songwriter myself, I particularly enjoyed reading the interview with Jeffrey Steele about What Hurts the Most for two reasons: one, because it’s interesting to hear other songwriters talk about how they modify their original inspirations to make them more universal, and two, because no matter how many times I hear it, it’s always encouraging to be reminded that even a well-established hit writer like Jeffrey Steele has to watch his songs get cut and then dropped from albums, get cut and not released as singles, and so on.
[…] The song was initially inspired by losing my father. I just wanted to say something about that, but I kind of changed the meaning and made the song more of a love song so it would just be more universal to listen to. When I first heard the music, it was so sad, and after listening to it a few times, the lyrics kind of what fell out. […]
The cool part of the story is that the song was cut back in 2002 by Mark Wills. It never got released, so I kind of got a little bit sad about that because I was really close to the song. About a year and a half later, Faith Hill cut it, so we really had our fingers crossed when she made her current CD. Right near the end of the recording, they ended up dropping the song off the record. I was really upset about it because I really loved the song, and I felt like it had kind of gotten away from us. Then when I heard that [Rascal Flatts] were going to cut it, I was so excited. […]
See? Even the story has a story.
You all are a well-connected bunch. What’s the best story you’ve heard about the writing of a song?
This song was played at the funeral I attended of a 15 year old girl. I can’t hear it without thinking about her and the pain her family was in. I didn’t know that Steele wrote it.
I don’t have any access to any inside stories, but I think my favorite such story is about John Fred, who heard the Beatles’ song “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds” and mis-heard the lyrics as “Lucy in Disguise with Diamonds.” When someone corrected him, he decided to write the peppy, bubble-gum “Judy in Disguise (with Glasses)”, which also went on to pop success:
Find the book “Sing Your Heart Out, Country Boy.” The book is about great country songs and how they came to be.
I asked Johnny Russell one time what the story behind “Act Naturally” was. He said “None of your business.” Hee.
There’s a couple stories that stand out to me. The story behind “This Ole House” is great. Stuart Hamblen was hunting somewhere in the wilderness of California and it was really cold and snowy and he came upon an old cabin. There was a hound dog lying out in the front but there was no smoke coming from the chimney. Upon closer inspection, he discovered the cabin’s owner dead inside. Great song.
Another one that stands out to me is the standard “Release Me.” The writer, Eddie Miller, was at a club somewhere and there was a couple at the next table arguing. At one point in the argument, the woman said “Well, if you’d just release me and let me go….” I don’t know how many times it’s been recorded but it’s on the “Million Air” list that BMI has. I’m partial to another one of Eddie’s classics, although I don’t know how the idea was born, but, the song “Thanks A Lot”…my mother was there when they wrote it and she wrote it down for them as they were throwing lines around. They always called her the Midwife of that song. I’m gonna have to blog about Eddie sometime soon.