Dec
04
Posted on 12-04-2007 at 03:44pm
Filed Under (Environment, Ethics) by Katherine Coble on 12-04-2007

Rob Robinson is driving the Thinktrain to Recycleville.

Is recycling a ton of consumer waste something that an individual family should brag about?

The Curby program has proved wildly popular with some Nashville residents who brag of having up to three of the green, 96-gallon carts to fill with paper, aluminum and other recyclables for monthly pickup …

In Nashville, Curby came to homes automatically, and the convenience has made it a recycling method some love. “We have three containers and they’re usually full,” said Paul Brown, a retired minister in the Green Hills area. “I think the program ought to be used, if it can be.”

I am a frequent recycler, and I want to see our citywide recycling rates increase. Wouldn’t it be better for all of us, though, to find ways to divert as much of our household garbage as possible, from both the trash can and the recycling bin?

And Southern Beale has some of her own input on the issue as well.

Yesterday’s article on Nashville’s “Curby” program came at an interesting time, since I have been meaning to call Metro Public Works to get another green cart out at our place. Mr. Beale and I recycle, and since pick up is just once a month, our two 64-gallon bins are always filled to overflowing.

I have a little challenge with myself to see how little actual garbage I can generate. One week I actually got it down to one large garbage bag, but I suspect that’s because we ate out a lot that week. The truth is, we generate plenty of garbage at our house.

She has a lot more fascinating detail about the economics and politics of recycling as well. Many of those same questions were being asked by Ben at Taxing Tennessee. Actually, they’re being asked by a man called Nate from Lawrenceburg.

Crawford, who terms himself a “country boy from Lawrenceburg,” never used it, and his questions about the program have only grown.

“I did not want my tax dollars spent for that. I feel the same way now when it’s only being used by 37 percent of the people.

I personally live outside the district where Metro picks up the trash, and I have to pay for my own trash pickup–and should I be interested–my own recycling. Frankly I still think that if everyone had to pay for their own trash pickup and also pay a poundage rate we’d see a lot less trash. It’s sort of like how people make sure to turn off the lights if they’re getting big electric bills. Hitting the wallet is the best way to reduce waste.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Furl
  • RawSugar
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • SphereIt
    Read More   

Comments

Christian on 4 December, 2007 at 5:17 pm #

Every Wednesday you can drive through my neighborhood and see trash cans whose lids can’t even close because they are overflowing with garbage.

We are just a family of two, but we still only have about 3 bags of trash every two weeks. We compost our organic wastes, too (except meat and citrus).

Last week, we took three months of recycling to our local waste center. But before we did that, we weighed everything to see about how much we prevent from filling the Middle Point landfill next to our county’s drinking supply - the Stones River. I forgot how many pounds (I’ll tally it and post it later) each category was, but it came to about a bag of trash every week, or a whopping 52 bags of trash in 2007 that did not go to Middle Point.

Every family can make a huge difference in the way we manage our resources. We pay for our own trash pick up, too. We used to pay for recycling pick up, but they would only take certain things. Now we do that ourselves.


Magniloquence on 4 December, 2007 at 5:28 pm #

That’s a good question. I hadn’t really thought about it much one way or another.

We don’t produce too much trash, but there’s only the two of us and we aren’t home all that often. Even so, one of the things that immediately occurred to me was the awkward class dimension to this kind of thing.

Composting organic waste works pretty well when you have a yard to do it in. Although you can technically do it inside, it’s harder and messier, and can often be more trouble than it’s worth (what exactly are you going to do with it when it’s done, if you don’t own anything you can put it on?). While we technically have a yard (at least until the move), our landlords are adamant that we not hang anything back there (so no drying clothes on a line, which sucks because we don’t have a washer/dryer, either), not make a mess, disrupt the grass, etc. Higher class food generally (though certainly not always) tends to come in more easily recycled (or otherwise reused) containers, while cheap stuff often comes in cheap plastic the recycling people just toss outright.

This isn’t at all to say it’s impossible to cut down if you don’t have much money. Of course you can, and you should, and it’s likely to have other benefits too. What I was trying to point out is that the things that usually come out first in conversations like this - compost your organics, use cloth bags instead of the plastic ones they give you, recycle and reuse like mad - are pretty well bound up in circumstance.

(I include things like geography under circumstance… places that are less overly concrete-y than SoCal probably have more houses with yards, for instance.)


Southern Beale on 5 December, 2007 at 11:04 am #

My post (which I admit was longer than most) basically says the same thing … That’s the idea behind the Austin program, where you are charged based on the size of your trash receptacle.

I said libertarians would swoon, didn’t I?

:-)